4 600+ tyres 100+ tests 460 000+ prices tracked

Comparison Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3 vs Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5

Overall rating
PTI – Pneutesty Index
–
10,0
Discipline comparison
Snow
–
98 +5 %
28 tests
what it consists of Snow (3)
snow braking
–
100 +6 %
19 tests
snow traction
–
96 +5 %
18 tests
snow handling
–
97 +3 %
22 tests
Wet
–
93 +8 %
27 tests
what it consists of Wet (3)
wet braking
–
94 +10 %
19 tests
Aquaplaning
–
76 +5 %
19 tests
wet handling
–
88 +3 %
22 tests
Dry
–
100 +4 %
20 tests
what it consists of Dry (2)
dry braking
–
100 +6 %
18 tests
dry handling
–
98 +2 %
15 tests
Ice
–
77 +6 %
2 Tests
what it consists of Ice (2)
ice braking
–
77 +5 %
2 Tests
ice traction
–
91 +7 %
1 Test 1 test
Economy
–
85 +10 %
21 tests
what it consists of Economy (2)
efficiency (rolling resistance and consumption)
–
53 +1 %
19 tests
durability (wear and abrasion)
–
92 +19 %
6 tests
Noise and comfort
–
86 +2 %
19 tests
what it consists of Noise and comfort (2)
quietness (measured and subjective noise)
–
96 +2 %
15 tests
ride comfort
–
60 Not measured.
Technologies
3PMSF 3PMSF
✓
✓ Only in some sizes
M+S M+S
✓
✓
OE OE
✓ Only in some sizes
✓ Only in some sizes
Rim protection Rim protection
✓ Only in some sizes
✓ Only in some sizes
Reinforced profile Reinforced profile
✓ Only in some sizes
✓ Only in some sizes
ROF ROF
–
✓ Only in some sizes this one only
Sound Sound
–
✓ Only in some sizes this one only
Suitable for EVs Suitable for EVs
–
✓ Only in some sizes this one only
Comparison

Technologies

Highlighted in green — this tyre has these in addition to the others; grey ones are shared by all.

3PMSF 3PMSF M+S M+S OE OE* Rim protection Rim protection* Reinforced profile Reinforced profile*
3PMSF 3PMSF* M+S M+S OE OE* Rim protection Rim protection* Reinforced profile Reinforced profile* ROF (run-flat technology) ROF* Sound (noise reduction) Sound* Suitable for EVs Suitable for EVs*

* Only in some sizes

Comparison

Discipline comparison

A higher number and a longer line always mean a better tyre — also for noise (quieter), consumption (more efficient) and wear (lasts longer). compared with 172 winter tyres

For example, wet braking, aquaplaning, and handling — showing what makes up the category score.

Snow

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 from 67 measurements · 28 tests
beats 145 of 148
98 +4,9 %
Subcategories snow

snow braking

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 19 tests
beats 146 of 147
100 +5,5 %

snow traction

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 18 tests
beats 112 of 117
96 +4,8 %

snow handling

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 22 tests
beats 118 of 122
97 +3,4 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Wet

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 from 81 measurements · 27 tests
beats 160 of 172
93 +8,1 %
Subcategories wet

wet braking

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 19 tests
beats 160 of 171
94 +9,9 %

Aquaplaning

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 19 tests
beats 102 of 134
76 +4,8 %

wet handling

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 22 tests
beats 111 of 127
88 +2,5 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Dry

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 from 33 measurements · 20 tests
beats 132 of 133
100 +3,9 %
Subcategories dry

dry braking

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 18 tests
beats 132 of 133
100 +5,5 %

dry handling

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 15 tests
beats 114 of 117
98 +1,6 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Ice

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 from 3 measurements · 2 tests
beats 55 of 72
77 +5,9 %
Subcategories ice

ice braking

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 2 tests
beats 55 of 72
77 +5,4 %

ice traction

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 1 test
beats 20 of 23
91 +6,6 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Economy

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 from 27 measurements · 21 tests
beats 113 of 133
85 +10,1 %
Subcategories economy

efficiency (rolling resistance and consumption)

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 19 tests
beats 67 of 128
53 +1,4 %

durability (wear and abrasion)

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 6 tests
beats 87 of 95
92 +18,7 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Noise and comfort

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 from 15 measurements · 19 tests
beats 109 of 128
86 +1,7 %
Subcategories noise and comfort

quietness (measured and subjective noise)

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5 15 tests
beats 121 of 126
96 +1,7 %

ride comfort

Michelin PILOT ALPIN PA3
– Not measured.
Michelin PILOT ALPIN 5
beats 38 of 64
60 Not measured.

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.