4 600+ tyres 100+ tests 460 000+ prices tracked

Comparison Pirelli SCORPION WINTER vs Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2

7.3 Winter
SCORPION WINTER
Pirelli
235/55R18 104H PIRELLI SCORPION WINTER XL RP
SUV / 4×4 Standard-sport
Rolling resistance C Wet grip C Noise B
from 196 €
8.6 Winter
SCORPION WINTER 2
Pirelli
235/55R18 104H PIRELLI SCORPION WINTER 2 ,XL ,3PMSF
SUV / 4×4 Standard-sport
Rolling resistance C Wet grip A Noise B
from 179 €
7.3 SCORPION WINTER SCORPION WINTER from 196 €
8.6 SCORPION WINTER 2 SCORPION WINTER 2 from 179 €
Overall rating
PTI – Pneutesty Index
7,3
8,6
Price from
196 €
179 € ▲ cheapest
EU label
Rolling resistance C Wet grip C Noise B
Rolling resistance C Wet grip A Noise B
Tyre profiles
Snow Wet Dry Economy Noise and comfort best of the selected middle of the selected Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Snow Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Wet Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Dry Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Economy Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Noise and comfort Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Snow Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Wet Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Dry Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Economy Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Noise and comfort

Click on a tyre name in the chart to hide or show it. The axis compares only the selected tyres with each other — the edge represents the best of them. The shape here doesn't indicate how a tyre performs overall, but which of the selected ones is better.

Discipline comparison
Snow
38 ≈ average
3 Tests
67 +2 % ▲
5 tests
what it consists of Snow (3)
snow braking
40 ≈ average
3 Tests
55 +1 % ▲
5 tests
snow traction
39 ≈ average
2 Tests
72 +3 % ▲
5 tests
snow handling
36 ≈ average
3 Tests
85 +2 % ▲
5 tests
Wet
40 +2 %
3 Tests
86 +5 % ▲
5 tests
what it consists of Wet (3)
wet braking
54 +4 %
3 Tests
92 +9 % ▲
5 tests
Aquaplaning
32 −3 %
3 Tests
60 ≈ average ▲
5 tests
wet handling
56 +2 %
3 Tests
95 +3 % ▲
5 tests
Dry
80 +2 % ▲
3 Tests
76 +2 %
5 tests
what it consists of Dry (2)
dry braking
79 +2 %
3 Tests
88 +3 % ▲
5 tests
dry handling
78 +2 % ▲
3 Tests
42 ≈ average
5 tests
Ice
– Not measured.
– Not measured.
Economy
62 −4 % ▲
3 Tests no wear measurement
11 −6 %
5 tests no wear measurement
what it consists of Economy (1)
efficiency (rolling resistance and consumption)
61 ≈ average ▲
3 Tests
11 −4 %
5 tests
Noise and comfort
26 ≈ average
3 Tests noise only
97 +1 % ▲
5 tests
what it consists of Noise and comfort (2)
quietness (measured and subjective noise)
38 ≈ average
3 Tests
98 +1 % ▲
5 tests
ride comfort
– Not measured.
20 Not measured.
Technologies
3PMSF 3PMSF
✓
–
M+S M+S
✓
–
Reinforced profile Reinforced profile
✓
–
OE OE
✓ this one only
–
Rim protection Rim protection
✓ this one only
–
Comparison

Technologies

Highlighted in green — this tyre has these in addition to the others; grey ones are shared by all.

3PMSF 3PMSF M+S M+S Reinforced profile Reinforced profile OE OE Rim protection Rim protection
none
Comparison

Tyre profiles

The shape will show at a glance which of the selected tyres is stronger in which aspect.

Snow Wet Dry Economy Noise and comfort best of the selected middle of the selected Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Snow Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Wet Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Dry Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Economy Pirelli SCORPION WINTER – Noise and comfort Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Snow Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Wet Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Dry Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Economy Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 – Noise and comfort

Click on a tyre name in the chart to hide or show it. The axis compares only the selected tyres with each other — the edge represents the best of them. The shape here doesn't indicate how a tyre performs overall, but which of the selected ones is better.

Comparison

Discipline comparison

A higher number and a longer line always mean a better tyre — also for noise (quieter), consumption (more efficient) and wear (lasts longer). PTI compared with all winter tyres · rank in size 235/55 R18 among 46 available

For example, wet braking, aquaplaning, and handling — showing what makes up the category score.

Snow

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER from 8 measurements · 3 tests
beats 21 of 56
38 ≈ average
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 from 17 measurements · 5 tests
beats 37 of 56
67 +1,9 %

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 is the best.

Subcategories snow

snow braking

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 20 of 56
40 ≈ average
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 26 of 56
55 +1,2 %

snow traction

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 tests
beats 21 of 51
39 ≈ average
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 34 of 51
72 +2,8 %

snow handling

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 22 of 50
36 ≈ average
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 39 of 50
85 +2,1 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Wet

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER from 10 measurements · 3 tests
beats 24 of 61
40 +1,9 %
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 from 24 measurements · 5 tests
beats 52 of 61
86 +4,7 %

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 is the best.

Subcategories wet

wet braking

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 24 of 61
54 +3,9 %
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 53 of 61
92 +9,2 %

Aquaplaning

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 17 of 54
32 −2,5 %
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 29 of 54
60 ≈ average

wet handling

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 25 of 51
56 +1,7 %
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 48 of 51
95 +2,8 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Dry

🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER from 6 measurements · 3 tests
beats 42 of 53
80 +1,7 %
Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 from 10 measurements · 5 tests
beats 40 of 53
76 +1,5 %

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER is the best.

Subcategories dry

dry braking

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 39 of 53
79 +2,3 %
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 44 of 53
88 +3,1 %

dry handling

🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 31 of 47
78 +1,5 %
Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 17 of 47
42 ≈ average

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Economy

🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER from 3 measurements · 3 tests no wear measurement
beats 32 of 52
62 −4,0 %
Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 from 5 measurements · 5 tests no wear measurement
beats 5 of 52
11 −6,4 %

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER is the best.

Subcategories economy

efficiency (rolling resistance and consumption)

🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 31 of 49
61 ≈ average
Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 7 of 49
11 −4,4 %

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.

Noise and comfort

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER from 3 measurements · 3 tests noise only
beats 13 of 51
26 ≈ average
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 from 5 measurements · 5 tests
beats 49 of 51
97 +1,0 %

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 is the best.

Subcategories noise and comfort

quietness (measured and subjective noise)

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 3 tests
beats 20 of 50
38 ≈ average
🏆 Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2 5 tests
beats 48 of 50
98 +1,1 %

ride comfort

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER
– Not measured.
Pirelli SCORPION WINTER 2
beats 7 of 30
20 Not measured.

A high percentile in one subcategory and a low one in another gives an average value — here you can see which one determined it.