Comparison Vredestein WINTRAC PRO+ vs Pirelli SCORPION WINTER

Vredestein

Overall rating

PTI – Pneutesty Index

7,9

7,3

Discipline comparison

Snow

58 +2 %

16 tests

38 ≈ average

3 Tests

what it consists of Snow (3)

snow braking

65 +2 %

15 tests

38 ≈ average

3 Tests

snow traction

66 +2 %

14 tests

41 ≈ average

2 Tests

snow handling

43 ≈ average

11 tests

39 ≈ average

3 Tests

Wet

83 +6 %

16 tests

52 +3 %

3 Tests

what it consists of Wet (3)

wet braking

78 +6 %

14 tests

51 +4 %

3 Tests

Aquaplaning

58 +3 %

15 tests

29 −3 %

3 Tests

wet handling

85 +3 %

11 tests

56 +2 %

3 Tests

Dry

47 ≈ average

15 tests

85 +2 %

3 Tests

what it consists of Dry (2)

dry braking

42 ≈ average

15 tests

80 +2 %

3 Tests

dry handling

43 ≈ average

11 tests

73 +1 %

3 Tests

Ice

69 +1 %

3 Tests

– Not measured.

what it consists of Ice (1)

ice braking

71 +1 %

3 Tests

– Not measured.

Economy

5 −9 %

13 tests

58 −3 %

3 Tests bez opotrebenia

what it consists of Economy (2)

efficiency (rolling resistance and consumption)

6 −4 %

12 tests

64 ≈ average

3 Tests

durability (wear and abrasion)

7 −15 %

5 tests

– Not measured.

Noise and comfort

72 ≈ average

14 tests

27 ≈ average

3 Tests noise only

what it consists of Noise and comfort (2)

quietness (measured and subjective noise)

11 ≈ average

13 tests

39 ≈ average

3 Tests

ride comfort

37 Not measured.

– Not measured.

Technologies

3PMSF

✓

✓ Only in some sizes

M+S

✓ Only in some sizes

Rim protection

✓ Only in some sizes

Suitable for EVs

✓ Only in some sizes

Reinforced profile

✓ Only in some sizes

–

✓ Only in some sizes iba táto

ROF

–

✓ Only in some sizes iba táto

Seal

–

✓ Only in some sizes iba táto

Sound

–

✓ Only in some sizes iba táto

Comparison

Technologies

Highlighted in green — this tyre has these in addition to the others; grey ones are shared by all.

3PMSF

M+S*

Rim protection*

Suitable for EVs*

Reinforced profile*

3PMSF*

M+S*

Rim protection*

Suitable for EVs*

Reinforced profile*

* Only in some sizes

Comparison

Discipline comparison

A higher number and a longer line always mean a better tyre — also for noise (quieter), consumption (more efficient) and wear (lasts longer). compared with 169 winter tyres

Vredestein WINTRAC PRO+

Pirelli SCORPION WINTER

Snow

58 +2 %

16 tests

38 ≈ average

3 Tests

what it consists of Snow (3)

snow braking

65 +2 %

15 tests

38 ≈ average

3 Tests

snow traction

66 +2 %

14 tests

41 ≈ average

2 Tests

snow handling

43 ≈ average

11 tests

39 ≈ average

3 Tests

Wet

83 +6 %

16 tests

52 +3 %

3 Tests

what it consists of Wet (3)

wet braking

78 +6 %

14 tests

51 +4 %

3 Tests

Aquaplaning

58 +3 %

15 tests

29 −3 %

3 Tests

wet handling

85 +3 %

11 tests

56 +2 %

3 Tests

Dry

47 ≈ average

15 tests

85 +2 %

3 Tests

what it consists of Dry (2)

dry braking

42 ≈ average

15 tests

80 +2 %

3 Tests

dry handling

43 ≈ average

11 tests

73 +1 %

3 Tests

Ice

69 +1 %

3 Tests

– Not measured.

what it consists of Ice (1)

ice braking

71 +1 %

3 Tests

– Not measured.

Economy

5 −9 %

13 tests

58 −3 %

3 Tests bez opotrebenia

what it consists of Economy (2)

efficiency (rolling resistance and consumption)

6 −4 %

12 tests

64 ≈ average

3 Tests

durability (wear and abrasion)

7 −15 %

5 tests

– Not measured.

Noise and comfort

72 ≈ average

14 tests

27 ≈ average

3 Tests noise only

what it consists of Noise and comfort (2)

quietness (measured and subjective noise)

11 ≈ average

13 tests

39 ≈ average

3 Tests

ride comfort

37 Not measured.

– Not measured.